RUTGERS UNIVERSITY
SENATE
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
M I N U T E S
March 11, 2011
MEMBERS PRESENT: Binetti, David, Fishbein, Gillett,
Gould, Leath, Panayotatos (Chair), Rabinowitz,
Swalagin
(Executive Secretary), Thompson
MEMBERS EXCUSED: Barnett, Bodnar, Borisovets, Bubb, Levine
ALSO ATTENDING:Cotter
(Faculty BOG Representative), Fehn (Administrative Liaison), Furmanski
(Administrative Liaison), McCormick (Administrative Liaison), Spiegel
(Budget and Finance Committee Chair)
The regular meeting of the University Senate Executive Committee was held on
Friday, March 11, 2011 at 1:10 p.m. in the Executive Board Room of
Administrative Services Building-III, Cook Campus.
1. Chairperson’s Report
Senate and Executive Committee Chairperson Paul Panayotatos called the
meeting to order at 1:20 p.m. He welcomed all present, and wished
everyone a nice spring break.
2. Secretary's Report
- The meeting agenda,
and the Minutes of the February 11, 2011 Senate Executive Committee Meeting were approved with one correction.
- The following communications were presented to, and acted upon by the
Executive Committee as indicated:
- Adam Helgeson has resigned as co-chair of the Student Affairs
Committee. Senators Robert Barraco and Lazaros Kolasis have agreed to
co-chair with Senator Rabinowitz for the remainder of this Senate year.
Appointment of two new co-chairs docketed below under "Standing
Committees." [Barraco and Kolasis were appointed co-chairs of the
Student Affairs Committee for the remainder of this Senate year.]
- PTL/Annual Appointee Faculty Senator Election to be conducted
by April 15 [Noted. Vice Presidents Fehn and Furmanski suggested
contacting directly both Vivian Fernandez and Don Smith to facilitate
this election in the same manner as last year's staff-Senator election.]
3. Administrative Liaison
President McCormick said there had been no new developments since his
last administrative report, but he and Vice Presidents Furmanski and
Fehn responded to questions or heard comments on topics including:
- his communications and relationship with Governor Christie;
- his response to the Senate's recommendations on Form 3A
[Furmanski said he found the recommendations valuable, and is preparing
a response.];
- administrative responses to Senate recommendations on Form 1A and
its analogs [Furmanski said computing staff had corrected some issues,
and that other issues were being looked into and considered.];
- RIAS functionality, and the need to disable popup blockers to view some RIAS functions;
- needed parking lot repairs;
- whether University Policy 60.5.4.E. is still in effect, which
mandates that "All persons employed by the university to teach are
required by law to complete an oath or affirmation of office."; and
- difficulties being encountered by staff who are required to collect and provide data for the VOIP phone service.
4. Standing Committees and Nominating
Panel
Replacement of Adam Helgeson as Student Affairs Committee (SAC)
Co-chair - Senators Robert Barraco and Lazaros Kolasis were appointed SAC
co-chairs with Senator Rabinowitz for the remainder of this Senate
year, replacing Adam Helgeson, who resigned.
Selection of Nominating Panel
Members for Election of 2011-12 Senate Officers, Executive Committee Members,
and Board Representatives - The
Executive Committee suggested several Senators to be solicited to join
the Nominating Panel for this year. Secretary Swalagin will contact
other Senators in addition to those suggested to ask if they will
participate in the nominations for the Senate's April 29 election.
Committee Reports:
University Structure and Governance Committee (USGC)
Response
to Charge S-1014 to Review New Brunswick Student Senate Membership
- USGC Chair Peter Gillett summarized his committee's response to
Charge S-1014 on reviewing New Brunswick student Senate membership. The
report was docketed for action at the March 25, 2011 Senate meeting.
Committee
Reports on Charge A-1102, Proposal for a New School of
Nursing-Camden - Responses to Charge A-1102, on the Proposal for a New School of Nursing-Camden, had been submitted from
the Budget and Finance Committee, from
the Faculty and Personnel Affairs Committee, and from
the Research, and Graduate and Professional Education Committee.
The reports were discussed by the Executive Committee, with the
discussion being led by Peter Gillett, who chairs the USGC,
which is the primary recipient of the three A-1102-response
reports. Senator Spiegel, chair of the Budget and Finance Committee,
spoke about the difficulties his committee encountered in trying to
determine the cost of moving from a department to a school, and of
funding the School of Nursing-Newark/New Brunswick. No member of the
Research, and Graduate and Professional Education Committee was present
at the meeting to discuss that report. Secretary Swalagin will contact
the chairs of all three committees (although FPAC and BFC chairs were
present at this meeting) to ask which members of those committees will
join the University Structure and Governance Committee for that
committee's March 25 discussion of Charge A-1102A, which will be based
in part on the A-1102 responses. Gillett and the Executive Committee
then discussed the USGC's continuing work on addressing Charge A-1102A.
[President McCormick left the meeting at 2:03 p.m.]
Academic Standards,
Regulations and Admissions Committee (ASRAC) Follow-Up Report on Response to
Charge S-0807, Add/Drop Period - ASRAC Co-chair Martha Cotter had written to Secretary Swalagin:
"I've now discussed the matter
with members of ASRAC and we are in agreement that we do not have
enough information to evaluate the pros and cons of extending both the
drop and add periods by one day and that we wish to extend the trial of
the extended add/drop period for one more academic year, with the
proviso that we will evaluate the trial thoroughly in the fall 2011 semester.
I will write up what we have agreed on and get it to you by the
middle of next week at the very latest. We would like to
docket it for the March meeting." Cotter summarized the ASRAC's
discussions and intent on this matter. The anticipated report was
docketed for action at the March 25, 2011 Senate meeting. Cotter will
draft and send to Swalagin a charge for the ASRAC to address the issue
of whether the extension of the add/drop period should be made
permanent.
Issues/Proposed
Charges:
Proposed Charge to
FPAC on NBFC Resolution on Deadline for Submission of Faculty Promotion Packets
to Deans by Academic Departments
- Paul Leath had submitted an issue for the Executive Committee to
consider charging to the Faculty and Personnel Affairs Committee, as
follows: "At the Senate meeting in Newark last Friday, I
was told that Dean Greenberg of the SAS in New Brunswick has decided to ignore
the Faculty Council resolution on "Deadline for Submission of Faculty Promotion
Packets to Deans by Academic Departments" which was passed on October 15, 2010
(http://nbfc.rutgers.edu/year10_11/packets.html).
As far as I know this proposed deadline may be presently observed by
all academic units except for the SAS in NB, but the SAS represents a
very large fraction of the Rutgers faculty. It is indeed a serious
problem for academic departments and faculty, and the proposed deadline
would be appropriate for all academic units in the University.
Hopefully further support and approval by the University Senate can get
the SAS, and all units, to comply. Therefore I propose that the
Senate Faculty Affairs and Personnel Committee be charged with
considering this NBFC resolution as soon as possible, with a deadline
of getting their recommendations to the full Senate at least by the
April 29, 2011 meeting, so that any resolution can hopefully be
implemented for the next round of faculty promotions this fall, 2011."
The issue was discussed at some length, with EVP Furmanski explaining
what steps he has taken to inform academic departments of, and
encourage compliance with, this New Brunswick Faculty Council
resolution. Paul Panayotatos suggested that the New Brunswick Faculty
Council Executive Committee issue this as a communication directly to
the SAS-NB. No Senate charge was issued.
5. University Senate March 25, 2011
Agenda
In addition to the committee reports docketed above, the Senate's March 25 agenda will also include:
6. New Business
Peter Gillett asked Ken Swalagin if the standing committees would be
meeting before the April 29, 2011 Senate organizational and regular
meetings. Swalagin said that, if the standing committees met even half
of their charge-response deadlines for this year, that the regular
meeting agenda would be very heavy, and that the meeting would need to
begin well before the usual 1:10 p.m. start time. Swalagin said he
could not know about the April Senate docket until the standing
committee chairs responded to the upcoming deadlines.
Paul Panayotatos informed the Executive Committee that Gayle Stein had
asked for official endorsement of her proposal to begin a Twitter feed
of Senate meetings. Panayotatos suggested that it may have been better
to refer the suggestion to Swalagin, as executive and corresponding
secretary of the Senate, but that he had told Stein he would raise the
issue with the Executive Committee. The Executive Committee declined to
endorse Stein's proposal for an official Twitter feed of Senate
meetings.
Leslie Fishbein raised an issue on how Rutgers might create more
effective teaching-assessment mechanisms that would help ensure that
students are properly placed in introductory courses, that there are
learning goals and rubrics for testing all of those goals, that grade
inflation is minimized, and academic outcomes in general are improved.
Fishbein will send Swalagin a draft proposal and charge to docket on
the April 8 Executive Committee agenda.
Joshua David, the New Brunswick student member of the Executive
Committee, reported on some recent Rutgers University Student Assembly
(RUSA) activities, including:
- a failed attempt to impeach Senator Jon Nyce on charges of ineligibility;
- David's own appointment to serve on the RUSA Executive Board,
which includes responsibilities as RUSA/University Senate liaison; and
- RUSA's support of an initiative to create an Asian-American
studies program, on which David will draft a proposal and charge for
the Senate Executive Committee to consider issuing to a Senate standing
committee at a future meeting.
7. Old Business
Peter Gillett asked about comments made at the previous Executive
Committee by Natalie Borisovets about the possibility of using clickers
for voting at Senate meetings. Chairperson Panayotatos suggested that
was a logistical issue that should be handled by the executive
secretary. Swalagin summarized his reasons for opposing use of clickers
at Senate meetings, including his belief that, as elected
representatives of constituencies comprising all of the Rutgers
community, Senators' votes on issues at open, public meetings should be
visible and identifiable to those constituents and other Senators as
well. Swalagin also commented on costs and related security
difficulties, and the absence of a clear need to begin using clickers.
8. Adjournment
The meeting
adjourned at 2:57 p.m.
Minutes Written and Submitted by,
Ken
Swalagin, Executive Secretary of the University
Senate